Abstract
We welcome the recent paper by Raposo et al. (2017) debating our Nature Comment on inadequacies in taxonomic governance and the impact this has on conservation and society (Garnett & Christidis 2017), as well as the opportunity to clarify our views. We admit to surprise at meanings read into our paper by Raposo et al. (2017) that we never intended and that we had not thought were there. As we have also made clear in a separate discussion of our paper (Garnett & Christidis 2018 in response to Thomson et al. 2018), we wish to make clear at the start: (i) that we have no wish to stifle taxonomic research, only to strengthen the legitimacy of its findings; and (ii) we believe that taxonomic research should not consider the consequences for conservation, or society, in its conclusions once transparent taxonomic criteria have been established (Garnett & Christidis 2007), but that taxonomists have an obligation to improve their governance to ensure taxonomic conclusions are of the highest standard.
References
Anonymous [World Spider Catalog] (2017) World Spider Catalog Version 18.5. Natural History Museum, Bern.
https://doi.org/10.24436/2Garnett, S.T. & Christidis, L. (2007) Implications of changing species definitions for conservation purposes. Bird Conservation International, 17 (3), 187–195.
https://doi.org/10.1017/s0959270907000809Garnett, S.T. & Christidis, L. (2017) Taxonomy anarchy hampers conservation. Nature, 546 (7656), 25–27.
https://doi.org/10.1038/546025aGarnett, S.T. & Christidis, L. (2018) Science-based taxonomy still needs better governance: Response to Thomson et al. PLOS Biology, 16(3), e2005249.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.2005249Dunlop, J. (2017) Comment on “A few bad scientists are threatening to topple taxonomy.” Smithsonian Magazine. Available from: https://disqus.com/by/disqus_NZGhjXII6a/ (accessed 13 September 2017)
Jackson, M.D., Scherz, M.D. & Zona, S. (2017) Taxonomy is not beholden to its dependencies: a rebuttal to Garnett and Christidis (2017). PeerJ Preprints. Available from: https://peerj.com/preprints/3060v1/ (accessed 13 September 2017)
Jones, B. (2017) A few bad scientists are threatening to topple taxonomy. Smithsonian Magazine. Available from: http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/the-big-ugly-problem-heart-of-taxonomy-180964629/#4ULwoIxw7PARr7OC.99 (accessed 13 September 2017)
Lind‐Riehl, J.F., Mayer, A.L., Wellstead, A.M. & Gailing, O. (2016) Hybridization, agency discretion, and implementation of the US Endangered Species Act. Conservation Biology, 30 (6), 1288–1296.
https://doi.org/10.1111/cobi.12747Raposo, M.A., Stopiglia, R., Brito, G.R.R., Bockmann, F.A., Kirwan, G.M., Gayon, J. & Dubois, A. (2017) What really hampers taxonomy and conservation? A riposte to Garnett and Christidis (2017). Zootaxa, 4317 (1), 179–184.
https://doi.org/10.11646/zootaxa.4317.1.10Schiff, D.M. & Wood, J. (2017) Petition of Pacific Legal Foundation, et al., for rule-making under the Administrative Procedure Act. Available from: https://pacificlegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/ESA-Taxonomy-Rulemaking-Petition.pdf (accessed 1 February 2018)
Thomson, S.A., Pyle, R.L., Ahyong, S.T., Alonso-Zarazaga, M., Ammirati, J., Araya, J.F., Ascher, J.S., Audisio, T.L., Azevedo-Santos, V.M., Bailly, N., Baker, W.J., Balke, M., Barclay, M.V.L., Barrett, R.L., Benine, R.C., Bickerstaff, J.R.M., Bouchard, P., Bour, R., Bourgoin, T., Boyko, C.B., Breure, A.S.H., Brothers, D.J., Byng, J.W., Campbell, D., Ceríaco, L.M.P., Cernák, I., Cerretti, P., Chang, C.H., Cho, S., Copus, J.M., Costello, M.J., Cseh, A., Csuzdi, C., Culham, A., D’Elía, G., d’Acoz, C. d’U., Daneliya, M.E., Dekker, R., Dickinson, E.C., Dickinson, T.A., van Dijk, P.P., Dijkstra, K.-D.B., Dima, B., Dmitriev, D.A., Duistermaat, L., Dumbacher, J.P., Eiserhardt, W.L., Ekrem, T., Evenhuis, N.L., Faille, A., Fernández-Triana, J.L., Fiesler, E., Fishbein, M., Fordham, B.G., Freitas, A.V.L., Friol, N.R., Fritz, U., Frøslev, T., Funk, V.A., Gaimari, S.D., Garbino, G.S.T., Garraffoni, A.R.S., Geml, J., Gill, A.C., Gray, A., Grazziotin, F.G., Greenslade, P., Gutiérrez, E.E., Harvey, M.S., Hazevoet, C.J., He, K., He, X., Helfer, S., Helgen, K.M., van Heteren, A.K., Hita Garcia, F.H, Holstein, N., Horváth, M.K., Hovenkamp, P.H., Hwang, W.S, Hyvönen, J., Islam, M.B., Iverson, J.B., Ivie, M.A., Jaafar, Z., Jackson, M.D., Jayat, J.P., Johnson, N.F., Kaiser, H., Klitgård, B.B., Knapp, D.G., Kojima, J., Kõljalg, U., Kontschán, J., Krell, F.-T., Krisai-Greilhuber, I., Kullander, S., Latella, L., Lattke, J.E., Lencioni, V., Lewis, G.P., Lhano, M.G., Lujan, N.K., Luksenburg, J.A., Mariaux, J., Marinho-Filho, J., Marshall, C.J., Mate, J.F., McDonough, M.M., Michel, E., Miranda, V.F.O., Mitroiu, M-D., Molinari, J., Monks, S., Moore, A.J., Moratelli, R., Murányi, D., Nakano, T., Nikolaeva, S., Noyes, J., Ohi, M., Oleas, N.H., Orrell, T., Páll-Gergely, B., Pape, T., Papp, V., Parenti, L.R., Patterson, D., Pavlinov, I.Y., Pine, R.H., Poczai, P., Prado, J., Prathapan, D., Rabeler, R.K., Randall, J.E., Rheindt, F.E., Rhodin, A.G.J., Rodríguez, S.M., Rogers, D.C., Roque, F.de O., Rowe, K.C., Ruedas, L.A., Salazar-Bravo, J., Salvador, R.B., Sangster, G., Sarmiento, C.E., Schigel, D.S., Schmidt, S., Schueler, F.W., Segers, H., Snow, N., Souza-Dias, P.G.B., Stals, R., Stenroos, S., Stone, R.D., Sturm, C.F., Štys, P., Teta, P., Thomas, D.C., Timm, R.M., Tindall, B.J., Todd, J.A., Triebel, D., Valdecasas, A.G., Vizzini, A., Vorontsova, M.S., Wagner, P., Watling, L., Weakley, A., Welter-Schultes, F., Whitmore, D., Wilding, N., Will, K., Williams, J., Wilson, K., Winston, J.E., Wüster, W., Yanega, D., Yeates, D.K., Zaher, H., Zhang, G., Zhang, Z.-Q. & Zhu, H.-Z. (2017) Taxonomy based on science is necessary for global conservation. PLOS Biology, 16, e2005075.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.2005075Voss, R.S., Helgen, K.M. & Jansa, S.A. (2014) Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence: a comment on Cozzuol et al. (2013) Journal of Mammalogy, 95, 893–898.
https://doi.org/10.1644/14-mamm-a-054