Abstract
John Hill (1714–1775), a brilliant man of many talents, was extremely productive, having produced more than a hundred books and pamphlets on a wide range of subjects, but despised by most contemporaries for his egotistical, argumentative, and provocative manner and for his slanderous writings that resulted in many heated disputes, among scientists and literati alike. Rejected in his attempts to join the Royal Society of London, he began a campaign of criticism and derision against the Society, its president, Martin Folkes (1690–1754), and the Philosophical Transactions, by publishing, under a pseudonym, satires on the Society that destroyed his chances of ever being elected to that body. Accusations of plagiarism followed much of his work. A previously unnoticed example of his wholesale lifting of the classification of fishes published in 1738 by Swedish naturalist Peter Artedi (1705–1735), is described. As for the Royal Society, Hill’s persistent satirization, which was mixed with sound critical advice, is said to have done more to improve the quality of the Philosophical Transactions than any other contemporary effort.
References
Allen, D.E. (1976) The Naturalist in Britain: A Social History. Allen Lane, London, 312 pp.
Allen, D.E. (2013) [Book review] Rousseau, George. The Notorious Sir John Hill: The Man Destroyed by Ambition in the Era of Celebrity. Archives of Natural History, 40 (2), 363–364, https://doi.org/10.3366/anh.2013.0187
Anonymous (1753) Conclusion of the account of dr. Hill’s general Natural History, &c. The Monthly Review; or, Literary Journal by Several Hands, 8 (2), 18–21.
Anonymous (1774) Dr. Hill, having been lately invested with the order of knighthood by the Swedish Ambassador, appeared at court for the first time with the proper ensigns. The Gentleman’s Magazine, and Historical Chronicle, Monday, 13 June 1774, 282.
Anonymous (1775a) On Wednesday died, at his house in Golden Square, the celebrated Sir John Hill. Derby Mercury, Friday, 24 November 1775, 3.
Anonymous (1775b) Same day, in the afternoon, at five o’clock, died of the gout in his stomach, Sir John Hill. Caledonian Mercury, Monday, 27 November 1775, 2.
Anonymous (1779) Short Account of the Life, Writings, and Character of the Late Sir John Hill, M.D. George Reid, Edinburgh, 21 pp.
Anonymous (1872) Sir John Hill. Temple Bar, A London Magazine for Town and Country Readers, 35, 261–266.
Artedi, P. (1738) Ichthyologia, sive Opera omnia piscibus scilicet: Bibliotheca ichthyologica, Philosophia ichthyologica, Genera piscium, Synonymia specierum, Descriptiones specierum. Omnia in hoc genere perfection, quam antea ulla. Posthuma vindicavit, recognovit, coaptavit et edidit Carolus Linnaeus, Med. Doct. et Ac. Imper. N. C. Conrad Wishoff, Leiden, 500 pp.
Boswell, J. (1791) The Life of Samuel Johnson, LL. D. Vol. 1. Printed by Henry Baldwin for Charles Dilly, London, xii + [16] + 516 pp.
Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (2018) Introduction. In: Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), Fame and Fortune: Sir John Hill and London Life in the 1750s. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 1–29.
Brant, C. (2018) The propagation of lives: Sir John who? In: Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), Fame and Fortune: Sir John Hill and London Life in the 1750s. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 63–84.
Browne, P. (1756) The Civil and Natural History of Jamaica. Printed for the author, and sold by T. Osborne & J. Shipton in Gray’s-Inn, London, vii + 503 pp.
Disraeli, I. (1814) Sir John Hill, with the Royal Society, Fielding, Smart, &C. In: Disraeli, I., Quarrels of Authors: Or, Some Memoirs for our Literary History, including Specimens of Controversy to the Reign of Elizabeth. Vol. 2. John Murray, London, pp. 84–85.
Easterby-Smith, S. (2018) John Hill, exotic botany and the competitive world of eighteenth-century horticulture. In: Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), Fame and Fortune: Sir John Hill and London Life in the 1750s. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 292–313.
Edwards, G. (1743–1764) A Natural History of Uncommon Birds: and of Some Other Rare and Undescribed Animals. Seven volumes, the final three volumes titled Gleanings of Natural History: Exhibiting Figures of Quadrupeds, Birds, Insects, Plants &c., Most of Which Have Not, Till Now, Been Either Figured or Described. 7 Vols. Printed for the author, at the College of Physicians in Warwick-Lane, London.
Elliott, B. (2018) Sir John Hill as botanist: the vegetable system. In: Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), Fame and Fortune: Sir John Hill and London Life in the 1750s. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 267–290.
Ellis, M. (2018) Coffeehouse sociability, science and public life in John Hill’s “The Inspector.” In: Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), Fame and Fortune: Sir John Hill and London Life in the 1750s. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 195–217.
Emery, C. (1942) “Sir” John Hill versus the Royal Society. Isis, 34 (1), 16–20, https://www.jstor.org/stable/225993
Ewers, C. (2018) The Inspector at large: investigating the spaces of London. In: Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), Fame and Fortune: Sir John Hill and London Life in the 1750s. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 219–239.
Fraser, K.J. (1994) John Hill and the Royal Society in the eighteenth century. Notes and Records of the Royal Society of London, 48 (1), 43–67, [http://www.jstor.org/stable/531419]
Henrey, B. (1975) British Botanical and Horticultural Literature Before 1800. Vol. 2. Oxford University Press, Oxford, xvi + [2] + 748 pp.
Hill, J. (1746a) Theophrastus’s History of Stones, with an English Version, and Critical and Philosophical Notes, Including the Modern History of the Gems, etc., Described by that Author, and of Many Other of the Native Fossils. C. Davis, printer to the Royal Society, London, xxiii + [1] + 211 + [1] pp.
Hill, J. (1746b) A letter from Mr. John Hill, apothecary, to the president, concerning the manner of the seeding of mosses. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 44, 60–66, https://doi.org/10.1098/rstl.1746.0014
Hill, J. (1746c) A letter from Mr. John Hill, apothecary, to the president, concerning Windsor Loam. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 44, 458–463, https://doi.org/10.1098/rstl.1746.0085
Hill, J. (1748) A General Natural History: The History of Fossils. Thomas Osborne, London, [12] + 654 + [6] pp.
Hill, J. (1748–1752) A General Natural History: Or, New and Accurate Descriptions of the Animals, Vegetables, and Minerals, of the Different Parts of the World; With Their Virtues and Uses, As Far as Hitherto Certainly Known, in Medicine and Mechanics. 3 Vols. Thomas Osborne, London.
Hill, J. (1750a) Lucina Sine Concubitu, a Treatise Humbly Addressed to the Royal Society: in Which is Proved, By Most Incontestable Evidence, Drawn from Reason and Practise, That a Woman May Conceive, and Be Brought to Bed, Without Any Commerce with Man. Mary Cooper, London, 32 pp.
Hill, J. (1751b) The Adventures of Mr. George Edwards, a Creole. Thomas Osborne, London, xvi + 269 pp.
Hill, J. (1751c) A General Natural History: Or, New and Accurate Descriptions of the Animals, Vegetables, and Minerals, of the Different Parts of the World; With Their Virtues and Uses, As Far as Hitherto Certainly Known, in Medicine and Mechanics, Vol. 2. Thomas Osborne, London, xxvi + 642 + [7] pp.
Hill, J. (1752) An History of Animals, Containing Descriptions of the Birds, Beasts, Fishes, and Insects, of the Several Parts of the World; and Including Accounts of the Several Classes of Animalcules, Visible Only by the Assistance of Microscopes. Thomas Osborne, London, [8] + 584 + [4] pp.
Hill, J. (1759–1775) The Vegetable System, Or, a Series of Experiments, and Observations Tending to Explain the Internal Structure, and the Life of Plants; their Growth, and Propagation; the Number, Proportion, and Disposition of their Constituent Parts; with the True Course of Their Juices; the Formation of the Embryo, the Construction of the Seed, and the Encrease from that State to Perfection. Including a New Anatomy of Plants. The Whole from Nature Only. 26 Vols. Printed at the expense of the author and sold by Robert Baldwin, London.
Jones, E.D. (2018) Sir John Hill and friendship. In: Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), Fame and Fortune: Sir John Hill and London Life in the 1750s. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 85–103.
Laundon, J.R. (1981) The date of birth of Sir John Hill. Archives of Natural History, 10 (1), 65–66, https://doi.org/10.3366/anh.1981.10.1.65
Linnaeus, C. (1735) Systema naturae, sive regna tria naturae systematice proposita per classes, ordines, genera, & species. Theodorum Haak, Leiden, [12] pp.
Morris, A.D. (1960) “Sir” John Hill, M.A., M.D. (1706–1775): apothecary, botanist, playwright, actor, novelist, journalist. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 53 (1), 55–60.
Nelson, E.C. (1995) Patrick Browne and the flowers of mayo: a biographical essay. In: Nelson, E.C. & Walsh, W.F. (Eds.), The Flowers of Mayo, Dr. Patrick Browne’s Fasciculus plantarum Hiberniae, 1788. Eìamonn de Buìrca for Edmund Burke, Dublin, pp. 1–27.
Nelson, E.C. (1997) Patrick Browne’s The Civil and Natural History of Jamaica (1756, 1789). Archives of Natural History, 24 (3), 327–336, https://doi.org/10.3366/anh.1997.24.3.327
Nelson, E.C. (2001) Patrick Browne M.D. (c. 1720–1790), an Irish doctor in the Caribbean: his residence on Saint Croix (1757–1765) and his unpublished accounts of volcanic activity on Montserrat. Archives of Natural History, 28 (1), 135–147, https://doi.org/10.3366/anh.2001.28.1.135
Nelson, E.C. & Pietsch, T.W. (2022) Sir John Hill (1714–1775): Where was he buried? Archives of Natural History, 49 (2), 419–422, https://doi.org/10.3366/anh.2022.0803
O’Connor, B. (2004) Hill, Sir John (bap. 1714, d. 1775). Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford. Available from: http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/13281 (accessed 10 April 2022)
Peakman, J. (2018) John Hill and his erotic satires, In: Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), Fame and Fortune: Sir John Hill and London Life in the 1750s. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 153–169.
Pietsch, T.W. & Aili, H. (2022) Swedish naturalist Peter Artedi (1705–1735) and his place in the history of biosystematics as exemplified by his Ichthyologia sive opera omnia piscibus of 1738. Zootaxa, 5169 (6), 589–598, https://doi.org/10.11646/zootaxa.5169.6.5
Porter, R. (1983) [Book review]. In: Rousseau, G.S. (Ed.), The Letters and Papers of Sir John Hill, 1714–1775. Medical History, 27 (1), pp. 85.
Rounce, A. (2018) “Unassisted Hill”: Churchill’s satire and the fate of the virtuoso. In: Brant, C. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), Fame and Fortune: Sir John Hill and London Life in the 1750s. Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 137–152.
Rousseau, G.S. (1970) The much-maligned doctor “Sir” John Hill (1707–1775). Journal of the American Medical Association, 212 (1), 103–108, https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.1970.03170140059010
Rousseau, G.S. (1978) John Hill, universal genius manqué: remarks on his life and times, with a checklist of his works. In: Lemay, J.A.L. & Rousseau, G.S. (Eds.), The Renaissance Man in the Eighteenth Century. Clark Memorial Library, Los Angeles, pp. 45–129.
Rousseau, G.S. (1982) The Letters and Papers of Sir John Hill. AMS Press Inc., New York, xliv + 208 pp.
Rousseau, G.S. (2006) Curiosity and the lusus naturae: the case of “Proteus” Hill. In: Evans, R.J.W. & Marr, A. (Eds.), Curiosity and Wonder from the Renaissance to the Enlightenment. Ashgate, Aldershot, pp. 213–249.
Rousseau, G.S. (2012) The Notorious Sir John Hill: The Man Destroyed by Ambition in the Era of Celebrity. Lehigh University Press, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, xxxi + 389 pp.
Severino, M.A. (1655) De piscibus in sicco viventibus. Ex typographia Camilli Caualli, financed by Alberti Tarini, Naples, [5] + 70 pp.
Stafleu, F.A. (1971) Linnaeus and Linnaeans: The Spreading of Their Ideas in Systematic Botany, 1735–1789. International Bureau for Plant Taxonomy and Nomenclature, Utrecht, xvi + 386 pp.
Stearn, W.T. (1957) An introduction to the Species Plantarum and cognate botanical works of Carl Linnaeus. In: Linnaeus, C., Species plantarum: A Facsimile of the First Edition, 1753. Ray Society, London, pp. 1–176.
Stearn, W.T. (1967) Hill’s “The British Herbal” (1756–1757). Taxon, 16 (6), 494–498, https://doi.org/10.2307/1216952
Sypher, W. (1939) The West-Indian as a “character” in the eighteenth century. Studies in Philology, 36 (3), 503–520. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4172451
Willughby, F. (1686) De historia piscium libri quatuor, jussu et sumptibus Societatis Regiae Londinensis editi. In quibus non tantum de piscibus in genere agitur, sed & species omnes, tum ab aliis traditae, tum novae & nondum editae bene multae, naturae ductum servante methodo dispositae, accurate describuntur. Theatro Sheldoniano, Oxford, [19] + 343 + 30 + [1] + [11] pp.
Woodruff, L.L. (1926) The versatile Sir John Hill, M.D. American Naturalist, 60, 416–442. https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdf/10.1086/280114