Abstract
In recent decades the butterfly Adelpha bredowii (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae), known in the USA as the California Sister, has been considered to be a polytypic array of taxa, composed of two, three or four subspecies. The most recent review of the genus (Willmott 2003a) recognized three: A. b. bredowii, A. b. eulalia (= guatemalensis) and A. b. californica. We used mitochondrial (COII) and nuclear (Tpi) DNA sequence data, coupled with a reevaluation of traditional morphological characters, to determine the phylogenetic relationships between members of the A. bredowii complex, and to elucidate their taxonomic status. Phylogenetic analysis of molecular data corroborated the monophyly of each of the three subspecies (sensu Willmott), with the following topology: (bredowii + (eulalia + californica)). Average levels of COII variation among these taxa were much greater than the average variation within each taxon (3.4% vs. 0.2%, respectively). There were no shared alleles among these taxa, even from localities where two lineages (bredowii and eulalia) were collected in exact sympatry and synchrony. The degree of genetic divergence, reciprocal monophyly, and absence of shared alleles between taxa, coupled with unique morphological and distributional attributes of each, strongly suggest that A. bredowii, A. eulalia and A. californica are all species-level taxa, as they are treated herein (rev. stat.). Adelpha bredowii is endemic to western, central and southern Mexico: the syntype female (herein designated Lectotype) most likely originated near Oaxaca City, Oaxaca. Adelpha eulalia occurs from Guatemala, through much of Mexico, to Arizona, New Mexico and Texas, United States (as permanent residents; further north as vagrants), and occurs in exact sympatry with A. bredowii at least in Oaxaca, Mexico, but potentially in much of western and southwestern Mexico. The syntype female of eulalia (herein designated Lectotype) most likely originated from south-central Mexico. Adelpha californica is allopatric with respect to the other two species, occurring in northern Baja California, much of California, far western Nevada, Oregon and Washington. Our results highlight the continuous need for systematic scrutiny of familiar taxa, and raise the prospect that the genus Adelpha may be comprised of many more hidden species.References
Aiello, A. (1984) Adelpha (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae): deception on the wing. Psyche, 91, 1–45.
Austin, G.T. & Austin, A.T. (1980) Butterflies of Clark County, Nevada. Journal of Research on the Lepidoptera, 19(1), 1–63.
Avise, J.C. & Walker D.E. (1999) Species realities and numbers in sexual vertebrates: Perspectives from an asexually transmitted genome. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 96, 992–996.
Beutelspacher, C.R. (1983) Mariposas diurnas de “El Chorreadero”, Chiapas (Insecta: Lepidoptera). Anales del Instituto de Biología, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (Zoología), 53(1), 341–366.
Bailowitz, R.A. & Brock, J.P. (1991) Butterflies of Southeastern Arizona. Sonoran Arthropod Studies, Inc., Tucson. ix + 342 pp.
Beltrán, M., Jiggins, C.D., Bull, V., Linares, M., Mallet, J., McMillan, W.O. & Bermingham, E. (2002) Phylogenetic discordance at the species boundary: comparative gene genealogies among rapidly radiating Heliconius butterflies. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 19, 2176–2190.
Brower, A.V.Z. (2006) Problems with DNA barcoding for species delimitation: ‘ten species’ of Astraptes fulgerator reassessed (Lepidoptera: Hesperiidae). Systematics and Biodiversity, 4(2), 127–132.
Brown, J.W., Real, H.G. & Faulkner, D.K. (1992) Butterflies of Baja California. Faunal Survey, Natural History, Conservation Biology. The Lepidoptera Research Foundation, Incorporated, 129 pp.
Burns, J.M. (1997) Presidential address 1996: on the beauties, uses, variation, and handling of genitalia. Journal of the Lepidopterists’ Society, 51(1), 1–8.
Butler, A.G. (1865) Description of the characters of six new species of Rhopalocerous Lepidoptera in the collection of the British Museum, with notes on the allied species. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London, 1865(2), 484–486.
Carpenter, G.D.H. & Hobby, B.M. (1944) On Limenitis bredowii Geyer (Lep., Nymphalidae) with description of a new subspecies and revival of another. A study in geographical distribution and speciation. Transactions of the Royal Entomological Society of London, 94, 311–346.
Comstock, J.A. (1927) Butterflies of California. A Popular Guide to a Knowledge of the Butterflies of California Embracing all of the 477 Species and Varieties at Present Recorded from the State. Published by author, Los Angeles, California, USA, 63 pp.
Comstock, J. A. & Dammers, C.M. (1932) The metamorphoses of Heterochroa bredowii californica Butl. (Lepid.). Bulletin of the Southern California Academy of Sciences, 30(3), 83–87.
Davenport, K. (2004) The Yosemite butterflies. The Taxonomic Report, 5(1), 1– 74.
DeSalle, R., Egan, M.G. & Siddall, M. (2005) The unholy trinity: taxonomy, species delimitation and DNA barcoding. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 360(1462), 1905-1916.
dos Passos, C.F. (1964) A synonymic list of the Nearctic Rhopalocera. Memoirs of The Lepidopterists’ Society, 1, 1–145.
Doubleday, E. (1848) The genera of diurnal Lepidoptera: comprising their generic characters, a notice of their habits and transformations and a catalogue of the species of each genus. Longman, Green & Longmans, London, United Kingdom, 250 pp.
Dyar, H.G. (1891) Descriptions of some butterfly larvae from Yosemite.- IV. The Canadian Entomologist, 23(12), 278–281.
Edwards, W.H. (1868–1897) The Butterflies of North America. Boston, Houghton, Mifflin & Co., Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Edwards, W.H. (1870–1873) Synopsis of North American butterflies. The American Entomological Society, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
Emmel, T.C. & Emmel, J.F. (1973) The Butterflies of Southern California. Natural History Museum, Los Angeles, California, USA, 148 pp.
Farris, J.S., Källersjö, M., Kluge, A.G. & Bult, C. (1995) Testing significance of incongruence. Cladistics, 10, 315–319.
Ferris, C.D. (1989) Supplement to: A Catalogue/Checklist of the Butterflies of America North of Mexico. Memoirs of the Lepidopterists’ Society 3(8), 1–103.
Ferris, C.D. & Brown, F.M. (1981) Butterflies of the Rocky Mountain States. University of Oklahoma Press. Norman, Oklahoma, USA, 442 pp.
Field, W.D. (1940) A distributional note on Heterochroa bredowii (Gayer) (Lepidoptera, Nymphalidae). Journal of the Kansas Entomological Society 13, 123.
Garth, J. S. & Tilden, J.W. (1986) California Butterflies. California Natural History Guide 51. University of California Press. Berkeley, California, USA, 246 pp.
Geyer, C.M. (1837) Zuträge zur Sammlung Exotischer Schmettlinge. Berlin, Germany.
Godman, F.D., & Salvin, O. (1879–1901) Biologia Centrali Americana. Zoología, Insecta, Lepidoptera Rhopalocera. Vols. II and III. Dulau & Co., Bernard Quaritch. London, UK, 487 pp.
Harry, J.L. (1994) Adelpha bredowi eulalia in Utah: a photo life history (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae). Holarctic Lepidoptera, 1, 62–63.
Hebert, P.D.N., Ratnasingham, S. & deWaard, J.R. (2003) Barcoding animal life: cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 divergences among closely related species. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, 270, S96–S99.
Hebert, P.D.N., Penton, E.H., Burns, J.M., Janzen, D.H. & Hallwachs, W. (2004) Ten species in one: DNA barcoding reveals cryptic species in the neotropical skipper butterfly, Astraptes fulgerator. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 101, 14812–14817.
Hewitt, G.M. (2004) Genetic consequences of climatic oscillations in the Quaternary. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B, 359, 183–195.
Hoffmann, C.C. (1940) Catálogo sistemático y zoogeográfico de los Lepidópteros Mexicanos. Primera parte, Papilionoidea. Anales del Instituto de Biología. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 11(2), 639-739.
Holland, W.J. (1931) The Butterfly Book, New and Thoroughly Revised Edition. A Popular and Scientific Manual, Describing and Depicting All the Butterflies of the United States and Canada. Doubleday, Doran & Co., Garden City, New York, USA, 424 pp.
Hovanitz, W. (1945) Geographical regularity in the variation and supposed mimicry of a butterfly, Limenitis bredowii. The American Naturalist, 79(784), 472–474.
Huelsenbeck, J.P. & Rannala, B. (1997) Phylogenetic methods come of age: testing hypotheses in an evolutionary context. Science, 276, 227–232.
Huelsenbeck, J.P. & Ronquist, F. (2001) MrBayes: Bayesian inference of phylogeny. Bioinformatics, 17, 754–755.
Kirby, W.F. (1871) A Synonymic Catalogue of Diurnal Lepidoptera. Van Voorst, London, UK, 690 pp.
Lamas, G. (2004) Limenitidinae. Checklist: Part 4A. Atlas of Neotropical Lepidoptera. Scientific Publishers, Gainesville, Florida, USA, 439 pp.
Lipscomb, D., Platnick, N. & Wheeler, Q. (2003) The intellectual content of taxonomy: a comment on DNA taxonomy. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 18, 65–66.
Llorente-Bousquets, J., Luis-Martínez, A. & Vargas-Fernández, I. (2006) Apéndice general de Papilionoidea: lista sistemática, distribución estatal y provincias biogeográficas, pp. 945–1009. In: Morrone, J. J. & J. Llorente-Bousquets (Eds.). Componentes Bióticos Principales de la Entomofauna Mexicana. Las Prensas de Ciencias, UNAM, Mexico City, Mexico, 1025 pp.
Luis-Martínez, A., Llorente-Bousquets, J. & Vargas-Fernández, I. (2003) Nymphalidae de México I (Danainae, Apaturinae, Biblidinae y Heliconiinae): distribución geografica e ilustración Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, and Comision Nacional Para el Conocimiento y Uso de la Biodiversidad (CONABIO), Mexico City, Mexico, 249 pp.
Mallet, J. & K.R. Willmott, K.R. (2003) Taxonomy: renaissance or tower of Babel? Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 18, 57–59.
de la Maza, R.F. (1987) Mariposas Mexicanas. Fondo de Cultura Económica, S.A. de C.V., Mexico City, Mexico, 302 pp.
de la Maza, R.G. & de la Maza, J. (1988) Notas sobre los Rhopalocera de la Sierra de Álvarez, San Luis Potosí, México (Lepidoptera). Revista de la Sociedad Mexicana de Lepidopterología, 11(2), 33–59.
de la Maza, R.G. & de la Maza, J. (1993) Mariposas de Chiapas. Gobierno del Estado de Chiapas, Mexico, 223 pp.
de la Maza, R.G., de la Maza, J. & White, A. (1989) La fauna de mariposas de México. Parte I. Papilionoidea (Lepidoptera: Rhopalocera). Revista de la Sociedad Mexicana de Lepidopterología, 12(2), 39–98.
Miller, J.C. & Hammond, P.C. (2003) Lepidoptera of the Pacific Northwest: caterpillars and adults. United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Health Technology Enterprise Team, Washington, D.C. 324 pp.
Miller, L.D. & Brown, F.M. (1981) A catalogue/checklist of the butterflies of America north of Mexico. Memoirs of the Lepidopterists’ Society, 2, 1–280.
Moritz, C. & Cicero, C. (2004) DNA barcoding: promise and pitfalls. PloS Biology, 2(10), 1529–1531.
Newcomer, E.J. (1964) Occurrence of certain Rhopalocera in Oregon and Washington. Journal of the Lepidopterists’ Society, 18(1), 47–50.
Orsak, L.J. (1977) The butterflies of Orange County, California. Museum of Systematic Biology Research Series no. 4, University of California, Irvine, USA, 349 pp.
Porter, A.H. (1988) Courtship of a model (Adelpha; Nymphalidae) by its probable Batesian mimic (Limenitis; Nymphalidae). Journal of Research on the Lepidoptera, 26, 255–256.
Poulton, E.B. (1909) Mimicry in the butterflies of North America. Annals of the Entomological Society of America, 11(4), 203–242.
Pratt, G.F. (1994) Evolution of Euphilotes (Lepidoptera) by seasonal and host shifts. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 51, 387–416.
Pratt, G.F., Wright, D.M. & Pavulaan H. (1994) The various taxa and hosts of the North American Celastrina (Lepidoptera: Lycaenidae). Proceedings of the Entomological Society of Washington, 96(3), 566–578.
Prudic, K.L., Shapiro, A.M. & Clayton, N.S. (2002) Evaluating a putative mimetic relationship between two butterflies, Adelpha bredowii and Limenitis lorquini. Ecological Entomology, 27, 68–75.
Pyle, R.M. (2002) The Butterflies of Cascadia. A Field Guide to all the Species of Washington, Oregon, and Surrounding Territories. Seattle Audobon Society, Seattle, Washington, USA. 420 pp.
Seitz, A. (1907–1935) Grossschmetterlinge der Erde. Fritz Lehmann’s Verlag, Stuttgart, Germany.
Skinner, H. (1911) Adelpha (Heterochroa) bredowii and californica (Lepidoptera). Entomological News, 22(9), 414–415.
Smith, M.A., Woodley, N.E., Janzen, D.H., Hallwachs, W. & Hebert, P.D. (2006) DNA barcodes reveal cryptic host-specificity within the presumed polyphagous members of a genus of parasitoid flies (Diptera: Tachinidae). Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 103(10), 3657–3662.
Stanford, R.E. & Opler, P.A. (1993) Atlas of western USA butterflies, including adjacent parts of Canada and Mexico. Published by authors, Denver, Colorado, USA, 275 pp.
Stout, T.L. (2005) Fundamental differences between the California Sister and the Arizona Sister (Adelpha bredowii californica vs. Adelpha bredowii eulalia). Bulletin of the Utah Lepidopterists’ Society, 12(1), 3.
Swofford, D.L. (2001) PAUP* Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony and Other Methods. Version 4.0b10. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, MA.
Tautz, D., Arctander, P. Minelli, A.R.H. & Vogler, P. (2003) A plea for DNA taxonomy. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 18, 70–74.
Toliver, M.E., Holland, R. & Cary, S.J. (1994) Distribution of Butterflies in New Mexico (Lepidoptera: Hesperioidea and Papilionoidea), Second Edition. Published by authors, Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA, 446 pp.
Warren, A.D. (2005) Lepidoptera of North America 6. Butterflies of Oregon. Their Taxonomy, Distribution, and Biology. Contributions of the C. P. Gillette Museum of Arthropod Diversity, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA, 408 pp.
Warren, A.D., Llorente-Bousquets, J.E., Luis-Martínez, J.A. & Vargas-Fernández, I.. (2007) Interactive listing of Mexican butterflies. Listado interactivo de la mariposas mexicanas. http://www.mariposasmexicanas.com
Westwood, J.O. (1850) Genus LV. Heterochroa, the genera of diurnal Lepidoptera: comprising their generic characters, a notice of their habits and transformations and a catalogue of the species of each genus. Longman, Green & Longmans, London, UK.
Willmott, K.R. (2003a) The genus Adelpha: its systematics, biology and biogeography (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae: Limenitidini). Scientific Publishers, Gainesville, Florida, USA, 322 pp.
Willmott, K.R. (2003b) Cladistic analysis of the Neotropical butterfly genus Adelpha (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae), with comments on the subtribal classification of Limenitidini. Systematic Entomology, 28, 279–322.
Zakharov, E.V., Smith, C.R, Lees, D.C., Cameron, A., Vane-Wright, R.I & Sperling, F.A.H. (2004) Independent gene phylogenies and morphology demonstrate a Malagasy origin for a wide-ranging group of swallowtail butterflies. Evolution, 58, 2763–2782.