Abstract
The question of how to define a species continues to divide biologists. Meanwhile, the application of different species concepts has led to disparate taxonomic treatments that confound conservationists and other biologists. The most widely followed guidelines to species designation in avian and other vertebrate taxonomy are Ernst Mayr’s Biological Species Concept (BSC) and Joel Cracraft’s version of the Phylogenetic Species Concept (PSC). Although the BSC is considered to be more conservative in its assignment of species status, there is a lack of research demonstrating differences in taxonomic treatment between the BSC and the PSC with reference to a multi-taxon multi-trait study system. We examined the case of five traditionally recognized species of shrike-babbler (Pteruthius) that have recently been divided into 19 species under the PSC. Re-analyzing previous morphological and molecular data and adding new vocal data, we propose a BSC classification of 9 species. However, taking into consideration geographic gaps in the sampling regime, we contend that additional data will likely reduce discrepancies between the total numbers of species designated under the PSC and BSC. The current PSC species total is a likely overestimate owing to species diagnosis based on characters that erroneously appear to be unique to a taxon at low sample size. The current BSC species total as here proposed is a likely underestimate on account of the conservative designation of taxa as subspecies in equivocal cases, e.g. where BSC species status is potentially warranted but may be masked by insufficient data.References
Alström, P. & Ranft, R. (2003) The use of sounds in avian systematics, and the importance of bird sound archives. Bulletin of the British Ornithologists’ Club, Supplement 123A, 114–135.
Cicero, C. & Johnson, N.K. (1998) Molecular phylogeny and ecological diversification in a clade of New World songbirds (genus Vireo). Molecular Ecology, 7, 1359–1370.
Collar, N.J. & Robson, C. (2007) Family Timaliidae (babblers). In: del Hoyo, J., Elliott, A. & Christie, D.A. (Eds), Handbook of the Birds of the World, Vol. 12. Lynx Edicions, Barcelona, pp. 284–285.
Cracraft, J. (1983) Species concepts and speciation analysis. Current Ornithology, 1, 159–187.
Currat, M., Ruedi, M., Petit, R.J. & Excoffier, L. (2008) The hidden side of invasions: massive introgression by local genes. Evolution, 62, 1908–1920.
de Queiroz, K. (2005) Ernst Mayr and the modern concept of species. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA, 102 Supplement 1, 6600–6607.
Funk, D.J. & Omland, K.E. (2003) Species-level paraphyly and polyphyly: frequency, causes, and consequences, with insights from animal mitochondrial DNA. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution and Systematics, 34, 397–423.
Haffer, J.H. (1997) Species concepts and species limits in ornithology. In: del Hoyo, J., Elliott, A. & Sargatal, J. (Eds), Handbook of the Birds of the World, Volume 4. Lynx Edicions, Barcelona, pp. 11–24.
Irestedt, M. & Ohlson, J.I. (2008) The division of the major songbird radiation into Passerida and ‘core Corvoidea’ (Aves: Passeriformes)—the species tree vs. gene trees. Zoologica Scripta, 37, 305–313.
Isaac, N.J.B., Mallet, J. & Mace, G.M. (2004) Taxonomic inflation: its influence on macroecology and conservation. Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 19, 464–469.
Jønsson, K.A., Irestedt, M., Fuchs, J., Ericson, P.G., Christidis, L., Bowie, R.C.K., Norman, J.A., Pasquet, P.E. & Fjeldså, J. (2008) Explosive avian radiations and multi-directional dispersal across Wallacea: Evidence from the Campephagidae and other Crown Corvida (Aves). Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 47, 221–236.
Kerr, K.C.R., Stoeckle, M.Y., Dove, C.J., Weigt, L.A., Francis, C.M. & Hebert, P.D.N. (2007) Comprehensive DNA barcode coverage of North American birds. Molecular Ecology Notes, 7, 535–543.
Kerr, K.C.R., Lijtmaer, D.A., Barreira, A.S., Hebert, P.D.N. & Tubaro, P.L. (2009) Probing evolutionary patterns in Neotropical birds through DNA barcodes. PLoS ONE, 4(2), e4379.
Krabbe, N. & Schulenberg, T.S. (1997) Species limits and natural history of Scytalopus tapaculos (Rhinocryptidae), with descriptions of the Ecuadorian taxa, including three new species. Ornithological Monographs, 48, 47–88.
Linnaeus, C. (1758) Systema Naturae per Regna tria Naturae, Secundum Classes, Ordines, Genera, Species, cum Characteribus, Differentiis, Synonymis, Locis. Tenth edition. Laurentii Salvii, Holmiae, Stockholm.
Mayr, E. (1942) Systematics and the Origin of Species, from the Viewpoint of a Zoologist. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 334 pp.
Mayr, E. (1969) Principles of Systematic Zoology. McGraw-Hill, New York, 475 pp.
Mayr, E. (1996) What is a species and what is not? Philosophy of Science, 63, 262–277.
Padial, J.M. & de la Riva, I. (2006) Taxonomic inflation and the stability of species lists: the perils of ostrich’s behaviour. Systematic Biology, 55, 855–869.
Payton, M.E., Greenstone, M.H. & Schenker, N. (2003) Overlapping confidence intervals or standard error intervals: What do they mean in terms of statistical significance? Journal of Insect Science, 3, 34–40.
Rasmussen, P.C. & Anderton, J.C. (2005) Birds of South Asia: The Ripley Guide. 2 vols. Lynx Edicions, Barcelona, 1060 pp.
Reddy, S. (2008) Systematics and biogeography of the shrike-babblers (Pteruthius): species limits, molecular phylogenetics, and diversification patterns across southern Asia. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 47, 54–72.
Reddy, S. & Cracraft, J. (2007) Old World Shrike-babblers (Pteruthius) belong with New World Vireos (Vireonidae). Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 44, 1352–1357.
Remsen, J.V. (2005) Pattern, process, and rigor meet classification. Auk, 122, 403–413.
Rheindt, F.E. (2006) Splits galore: the revolution in Asian leaf warbler systematics. Birding Asia, 5, 25–39.
Rheindt, F.E., Norman, J.A. & Christidis, L. (2008) DNA evidence shows vocalizations to be a better indicator of taxonomic limits than plumage patterns in Zimmerius tyrant-flycatchers. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, 48, 150–156.
Robson, C. (2000) A Field Guide to the Birds of South-east Asia. New Holland, London, 304 pp.
Samper, C. (2004) Taxonomy and environmental policy. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B, 359, 721–728.
Scharringa, J. (2005) Birds of Tropical Asia 3: Sounds and Sights DVD-ROM for Windows. Bird Songs International BV, Enschede.
Stein, R.C. (1963) Isolating mechanisms between populations of Traill's Flycatchers. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 107, 21-50.
Tamura, K., Dudley, J., Nei, M. & Kumar, S. (2007) MEGA4: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis (MEGA) software version 4.0. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 24, 1596–1599.
Thielcke, G. (1970) Vogelstimmen. Springer Verlag, Berlin, 158 pp.
Weckstein, J.D., Zink, R.M., Blackwell-Rago, R.C. & Nelson, D.A. (2001) Anomalous variation in mitochondrial genomes of White-crowned (Zonotrichia leucophrys) and Golden-crowned (Z. atricapilla) sparrows: pseudogenes, hybridization or incomplete lineage sorting? Auk, 118, 231–236.
Weir, J.T. & Schluter, D. (2008) Calibrating the avian molecular clock. Molecular Ecology, 17, 2321–2328.
Wheeler, Q.D. & Meier, R. (2000) Species Concepts and Phylogenetic Theory: A Debate. Columbia University Press, New York, 230 pp.
Zink, R.M. (2006) Rigor and species concepts. Auk, 123, 887–891.
Zink, R.M., Rising, J.D., Mockford, S., Horn, A.G., Wright, J.M., Leonard, M. & Westberg, M.C. (2005) Mitochondrial DNA variation, species limits, and rapid evolution of plumage coloration and size in the Savannah Sparrow. Condor, 107, 21–28.