Abstract
Elasmobranchii is a clade of chondrichthyans (cartilaginous fishes) that comprises sharks, skates and rays represented today by approximately 1,200 species. Chondrichthyans have a long evolutionary history dating back to the Late Ordovician (ca. 450 million years ago [Mya]) based on isolated dermal denticles (Janvier 1996). Other remains such as articulated skeletons and teeth are known from the Lower Devonian (ca. 410 Mya: Mader 1986; Miller et al. 2003). The fossil record of modern elasmobranchs (Neoselachii) can be traced back to the Early Permian (ca. 290 Mya) and is represented by isolated teeth (Ivanov 2005), with fossils of crown group sharks and rays appearing in Lower Jurassic (ca. 200 Mya) rocks (e.g., Cappetta 2012). Since their appearance in the geological record, elasmobranchs are mainly represented by isolated teeth, whereas articulated skeletons are very rare and restricted to a small number of fossil localities (e.g., Cappetta 2012). The scarcity of skeletal remains in their fossil record is due to their poorly mineralized cartilaginous skeleton that requires special taphonomical conditions to be preserved. Elasmobranch teeth, in contrast, are composed of highly mineralized tissues (hydroxyapatite) that have a strong preservation potential (Shimada 2006). In addition, elasmobranchs replace their teeth continuously over the course of their life span (polyphyodonty) and therefore shed thousands of teeth in their lifetime (Reif et al. 1978; Schnetz et al. 2016) leading to large numbers of potential fossils. These morphologically highly diverse isolated teeth constitute much of the rich fossil record of elasmobranchs, and largely form the basis of our understanding of elasmobranch diversity and evolution through geological time.
References
Agassiz, L. (1835-1843) Recherches sur les poissons fossiles, 3. Petitpierre, Neuchatel & Soleure, 390 + 32 pp.
Applegate, S.P. (1965) Tooth terminology and variation in sharks with special reference to the sand shark, Carcharias taurus Rafinesque. Contributions in Science, Los Angeles County Museum, 86, 1–18.
Bass, A.J., D’Aubrey, J.D. & Kistnasamy, N. (1973) Sharks of the east coast of southern Africa. I. The genus Carcharinus (Carcharhinidae). Investigational Report Oceanographic Research Institute, 33, 1–168.
Bass, A.J., D’Aubrey, J.D. & Kistnasamy, N. (1975a) Sharks of the east coast of southern Africa. II. The families Scyliorhinidae and Pseudotriakidae. Investigational Report Oceanographic Research Institute, 37, 1–64.
Bass, A.J., D’Aubrey, J.D. & Kistnasamy, N. (1975b) Sharks of the east coast of southern Africa. III. The families Carcharhinidae (excluding Mustelus and Carcharhinus) and Sphyrnidae. Investigational Report Oceanographic Research Institute, 38, 1–100.
Bass, A.J., D’Aubrey, J.D. & Kistnasamy, N. (1975c) Sharks of the east coast of southern Africa. IV. The families Odontaspididae, Scapanorhynchidae, Isuridae, Cetorhinidae, Alopiidae, Orectolobidae and Rhiniodontidae. Investigational Report Oceanographic Research Institute, 39, 1–102.
Bass, A.J., D’Aubrey, J.D. & Kistnasamy, N. (1975d) Sharks of the east coast of Southern Africa. V. The families Hexanchidae, Chlamydoselachidae, Heterodontidae, Pristiophoridae, and Squatinidae. Investigational Report Oceanographic Research Institute, 43, 1–50.
Bass, A.J., D’Aubrey, J.D. & Kistnasamy, N. (1976) Sharks of the east coast of southern Africa. VI. The families Oxynotidae, Squalidae, Dalatiidae and Echinorhinidae. Investigational Report Oceanographic Research Institute, 45, 1–103.
Bemis, W.E., Moyer, J.K. & Riccio, M.L. (2015) Homology of lateral cusplets in the teeth of lamnid sharks (Lamniformes: Lamnidae). Copeia, 103 (4), 961–972.
https://doi.org/10.1643/CG-14-109
Bigelow, H.B. & Schroeder, W.C. (1948) Fishes of the western North Atlantic, Part I: Lancelets, Cyclostomes, Sharks. Memoirs of the Sears Foundation for Marine Research Journal of Marine Research, 1, 59–576.
Bigelow, H.B. & Schroeder, W.C. (1953) Fishes of the sestern North Atlantic, Part II. Sharks, sawfishes, guitarfishes, skates and rays; chimaeroids. Memoirs of the Sears Foundation for Marine Research Journal of Marine Research, 1, 1–514.
Cappetta, H. (1980a) Les sélaciens du Crétacé supérieur du Liban. I : Requins. Palaeontographica Abteilung A, 168 (1-4), 69–148.
Cappetta, H. (1980b) Les sélaciens du Crétacé supérieur du Liban. II : Batoïdes. Palaeontographica Abteilung A, 168 (5-6), 149–229.
Cappetta, H. (1987) Mesozoic and Cenozoic Elasmobranchii, Chondrichthyes II. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart, 193 pp.
Cappetta, H. (2012) Chondrichthyes - Mesozoic and Cenozoic Elasmobranchii: Teeth. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart, 512 pp.
Compagno, L.J.V. (1970) Systematics of the genus Hemitriakis (Selachii: Carcharhinidae), and related genera. Proceedings of the California Academy of Sciences, 38, 63–97.
Compagno, L.J.V. (1988) Sharks of the order Carcharhiniformes. Princeton University Press, New Jersey, 486 pp.
Ebert, D.A. & Stehmann, M. (2013) Sharks, batoids, and chimaeras of the North Atlantic. FAO Species Catalogue for Fishery Purposes, 7. FAO, Rome, 523 pp.
Garman, S. (1913) The Plagiostomia (Sharks, Skates and Rays). Memoirs of the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard College, 36, 1–528.
Gruber, S.H. & Compagno, L.J.V. (1981) Taxonomic status and biology of the bigeye thresher Alopias superciliosus. Fishery Bulletin, 79 (4), 617–640.
Gudger, E.W. (1937) Abnormal dentition in sharks, Selachii. Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 73, 249–280.
Guinot, G., Adnet, S. & Cappetta, H. (2012) An analytical approach for estimating fossil record and diversification events in sharks, skates and rays. PloS ONE, 7, e44632.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0044632
Guinot, G. & Cavin, L. (2016) ‘Fish’ (Actinopterygii and Elasmobranchii) diversification patterns through deep time. Biological Reviews, 91 (4), 950–981.
https://doi.org/10.1111/brv.12203
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1987) Part A: Selachii. No. 1: Order: Hexanchiformes - Family Hexanchidae. Commissural teeth. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 57, 43–56.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1988) Part A: Selachii. No. 2a: Order: Carcharhiniformes – Family: Triakidae Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 58, 99–126.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1989) Part A: Selachii. No. 3: Order: Squaliformes – Families: Echinorhinidae, Oxynotidae and Squalidae. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 59, 101–157.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1990) Part A: Selachii. No. 2b: Order: Carcharhiniformes – Family: Scyliorhinidae. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 60, 181–230.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1991) Part A: Selachii. No. 2c: Order: Carcharhiniformes – Families: Proscylliidae, Hemigaleidae, Pseudotriakidae, Leptocharias and Carcharhinidae. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 61, 73–120.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1992) Part A: Selachii. No. 4: Order: Orectolobiformes – Families: Brachaeluridae, Ginglymostomatidae, Hemiscyllidae, Orectolobidae, Parascyllidae, Rhiniodontidae, Stegostomatidae. Order: Pristiophoriformes – Family: Pristiophoridae. Order: Squatiniformes – Family: Squatinidae Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 62, 193–254.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1993) Part A: Selachii. No. 1b: Order: Hexanchiformes – Family: Chlamydoselachidae; No. 5: Order: Heterodontiformes – Family: Heterodontidae; No. 6: Order: Lamniformes – Families: Cetorhinidae, Megachasmidae; Addendum 1 to No. 4: Order: Orectolobiformes; General glossary; Summary Part A. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 63, 185–256.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1994a) Part A, No. 1: Order: Hexanchiformes – Family: Hexanchidae. Odontological results supporting the validity of Hexanchus vitulus SPRINGER & WALLER, 1969 as the third species of the genus Hexanchus RAFINESQUE, 1810, and suggesting intrafamilial reordering of the Hexanchidae. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 64, 165–207.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1994b) Part B: Batomorphii. No. 1a: Order: Rajiformes – Suborder Rajoidei – Family: Rajidae; Genera and subgenera: Anacanthobatis (Schroederobatis), Anacanthobatis (Springeria), Breviraja, Dactylobatus, (Gurgesiella), Gurgesiella (Fenestraja), Malacoraja, Neoraja and Pavoraja. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 64, 165–207.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1995) Part B: Batomorphii. No. 1b: Order: Rajiformes – Suborder Rajoidei – Family: Rajidae; Genera and subgenera: Bathiraja (with a deep-water, shallow-water and transitional morphotype), Psammobatis, Raja (Amblyraja), Raja (Dipturus), Raja (Leucoraja), Raja (Raja), Raja (Rajella), Raja (with two morphotypes), Raja (Rioraja), Raja (Rostroraja), Raja lintea, and Sympterygia. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 65, 237–307.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1996) Part B: Batomorphii. No. 1c: Order Rajiformes- Suborder Rajoidei- Family: Rajidae - Genera and Subgenera: Arhynchobatis, Bathyraja richardsoni-type, Cruriraja, Irolita, Notoraja, Pavoraja (Insentiraja), Pavoraja ( Pavoraja), Pseudoraja, Raja (Atlantoraja), Raja (Okamejei) and Rhinoraja. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 66, 179–236.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1997) Part B: Batomorphii. No. 2: Order: Rajiformes - Suborder: Pristoidei - Family: Pristidae - Genera: Anoxypristis and Pristis; No. 3: Suborder: Rajoidei - Superfamily: Rhinobatoidea - Families: Rhinidae - Genera: Rhina and Rhynchobatus and Rhinobatidae - Genera: Aptychotrema, Platyrhina, Plathyrhinoidis, Rhinobatos, Trygonorrhina, Zanobatus and Zapteryx. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 67, 107–162.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1998) Part B: Batomorphii. No. 4a: Order Rajiformes - Suborder Myliobatoidei - Superfamily Dasyatoidea - Family Dasyatidae - Subfamily Dasyatinae - Genera: Amphotistius, Dasyatis, Himantura, Pastinachus, Pteroplatytrygon, Taeniura, Urogymnus and Urolophoides (incl. supraspecific taxa of uncertain status and validity), Superfamily Myliobatoidea - Family Gymnuridae - Genera: Aetoplatea and Gymnura, Superfamily Plesiobatoidea - Family Hexatrygonidae - Genus: Hexatrygon. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 68, 145–197.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (1999) Part B: Batomorphii. No. 4b: Order Rajiformes - Suborder Myliobatoidei - Superfamily Dasyatoidea - Family Dasyatididae - Subfamily Dasyatinae - Genus: Taeniura, Urogymnus, Urolophoides - Subfamily Potamotrygoninae - Genera: Disceus, Pleisiotrygon, and Potamotrygon (incl. supraspecific taxa of uncertain status and validity), Family Urolophidae - Trygonoptera, Urolophus and Urotrygon - Superfamily Myliobatidea - Family: Gymnuridae - Genus: Aetoplatea. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 69, 161–200.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (2000) Part B: Batomorphii. 4c: Order: Rajiformes - Suborder Myliobatoidei - Superfamily Dasyatoidea - Family Dasyatidae - Subfamily Dasyatinae - Genus: Urobatis, Subfamily Potamotrygoninae - Genus: Potamatrygon, Superfamily Plesiobatoidea - Family Plesiobatidae - Genus: Plesiobatis, Superfamily Myliobatoidea - Family Myliobatidae Subfamily Myliobatinae - Genera: Aetobatus, Aetomylaeus, Myliobatis and Pteromylaeus, Subfamily Rhinopterinae - Genus: Rhinoptera and Subfamily Mobulinae - Genera: Manta and Mobula. Addendum 1 to 4a: Erratum to Genus Pteroplatytrygon. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 70, 5–67.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (2002) Part B: Batomorphii. No. 4: Order Torpediniformes - Family Narcinidae - Subfamily Narcininae - Genera: Benthobatis, Diplobatis, Discopyge and Narcine, Subfamily Narkinae - Genera: Bengalichthys, Crassinarke, Heteronarce, Narke, Temera, and Typhlonarke, Family Torpedinidae - Subfamily Torpedininae - Genus: Torpedo - Subgenus T. (Tetronarke) and T. (Torpedo) and Subfamily Hypninae - Genus: Hypnos. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 72, 5–45.
Herman, J., Hovestadt-Euler, M. & Hovestadt, D.C. (2003) Part A: Selachii. Addendum to 1: Order Hexanchiformes-Family Hexachidae, 2: Order Carcharhiniformes, 2a: Family Triakidae, 2b: Family Scyliorhinidae, 2c: Family Carcharhinidae, Hemigaleidae, Leptochariidae, Sphyrnidae, Proscylliidae and Pseudotriakidae, 3: Order Squaliformes: Family Echinorhinidae, Oxynotidae and Squalidae. Tooth vascularization and phylogenetic interpretation. Bulletin de l’Institut Royal des Sciences Naturelles de Belgique, Biologie, 73, 5–26.
Hovestadt, D.C. & Hovestadt-Euler, M. (2013) Generic assessment and reallocation of Cenozoic myliobatins based on new information of tooth, tooth plate and caudal spine morphology of extant taxa. Palaeontos, 24, 1–66.
Ivanov, A. (2005) Early Permian chondrichthyans of the Middle and South Urals. Revista Brasileira de Paleontologia, 8 (2), 127–138.
Janvier, P. (1996) Early vertebrates. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 428 pp.
Kajiura, S.M. & Tricas, T. (1996) Seasonal dynamics of dental sexual dimorphism in the Atlantic stingray Dasyatis sabina. The Journal of Experimental Biology, 199 (10), 2297–2306.
Kaneko, M. & Goto, M. (2001) A consideration on the abnormal teeth of sharks. Journal of Fossil Research, 34, 18–30.
Kukulev, E.I. & Konovalenko, I.I. (1988) Two new species of sharks of the genus Scymnodalatias (Dalatiidae) from the North Atlantic and southeastern Pacific oceans. Voprosy Ikhtiologii, 28 (2), 315–319.
Last, P., White, W., Séret, B., Naylor, G., Carvalho, M. de & Stehmann, M. (2016a) Rays of the World. Csiro Publishing, Clayton (Australia), 790+IX pp.
Last, P.R., Carvalho de, M.R., Corrigan, S., Naylor, G.J.P., Séret, B. & Yang, L. (2016b) The Rays of the World project – an explanation of nomenclatural decisions. In: Last, P., White, W., Séret, B., Naylor, G., Carvalho, M. de & Stehmann, M. (Eds), Rays of the World: Supplementary information. Csiro Publishing, Clayton (Australia), pp. 1-10.
Lucifora, L.O., Cione, A.L., Menni, R.C. & Escalante, A.H. (2003) Tooth row counts, vicariance, and the distribution of the sand tiger shark, Carcharias taurus. Ecography, 26, 567–572.
https://doi.org/10.1034/j.1600-0587.2003.03532.x
Mader, H. (1986) Schuppen und Zähne von Acanthodien und Elasmobranchiern aus dem Unter-Devon Spaniens (Pisces). Göttinger Arbeiten Zur Geologie und Paläontologie, 28, 1–59.
Marramà, G., Carnevale, G., Engelbrecht, A., Claeson, K.M., Zorzin, R., Fornasiero, M. & Kriwet, J. (2017) A synoptic review of the Eocene (Ypresian) cartilaginous fishes (Chondrichthyes: Holocephali, Elasmobranchii) of the Bolca Konservat-Lagerstätte, Italy. PalZ, 1–31.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12542-017-0387-z
McCourt, R.M. & Kerstitch, A.N. (1980) Mating behavior and sexual dimorphism in dentition in the stingray Urolophus concentricus from the Gulf of California. Copeia, 1980 (4), 900–901.
https://doi.org/10.2307/1444479
Miller, R.F., Cloutier, R. & Turner, S. (2003) The oldest articulated chondrichthyan from the Early Devonian period. Nature, 425, 501–504.
https://doi.org/10.1038/nature02001
Moyer, J.K. & Bemis, W.E. (2016) Tooth microstructure and Replacement in the Gulper Shark, Centrophorus granulosus (Squaliformes: Centrophoridae). Copeia, 104 (2), 529–538.
https://doi.org/10.1643/CI-15-288
Müller, J.K. & Henle, F.G.J. (1838) Systematische Beschreibung der Plagiostomen. Veit and Co, Berlin, 200 pp.
Naylor, G.J.P. & Marcus, L.F. (1994) Identifying isolated shark teeth of the genus Carcharhinus to species: relevance for tracking phyletic change through the fossil record. American Museum Novitates, 3109, 1–53.
Nordell, S.E. (1994) Observations of the mating behavior and dentition of the round stingray, Urolophus halleri. Environmental Biology of Fishes, 39 (3), 219–229.
https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00005124
Raschi, W., Musick, J.A. & Compagno, L.J.V. (1982) Hypoprion bigelowi, a synonym of Carcharhinus signatus (Pisces: Carcharhinidae), with a description of ontogenetic heterodonty in this species and notes on its natural history. Copeia, 1982 (1), 102–109.
https://doi.org/10.2307/1444274
Reif, W.-E. (1976) Morphogenesis, pattern formation and function of the dentition of Heterodontus (Selachii). Zoomorphologie, 83, 1–47.
Reif, W.-E., McGill, D. & Motta, P. (1978) Tooth replacement rates of the sharks Triakis semifasciata and Ginglymostoma cirratum. Zoologische Jahrbücher (Anat.), 99, 151–156.
Sadowsky, V. (1969) On the dentition of the sand shark, Odontaspis taurus, from the vicinity of Cananéia, Brazil. Boletim do Instituto Oceanográfico, 18 (1), 37–44.
https://doi.org/10.1590/S0373-55241969000100005
Schnetz, L., Pfaff, C. & Kriwet, J. (2016) Tooth development and histology patterns in lamniform sharks (Elasmobranchii, Lamniformes) revisited. Journal of Morphology, 277 (12), 1584–1598.
https://doi.org/10.1002/jmor.20597
Shimada, K. (2002a) Dental homologies in lamniform sharks (Chondrichthyes: Elasmobranchii). Journal of Morphology, 251 (1), 38–72.
https://doi.org/10.1002/jmor.1073
Shimada, K. (2002b) Teeth of embryos in lamniform sharks (Chondrichthyes: Elasmobranchii). Environmental Biology of Fishes, 63 (3), 309–319.
https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1014392211903
Shimada, K. (2006) Types of tooth sets in the fossil record of sharks, and comments on reconstructing dentitions of extinct sharks. Journal of Fossil Research, 38 (2), 141–145.
Soares, K.D.A., Gomes, U.L. & Carvalho, M.R.D. (2016) Taxonomic review of catsharks of the Scyliorhinus haeckelii group, with the description of a new species (Chondrichthyes: Carcharhiniformes: Scyliorhinidae). Zootaxa, 4066 (5), 501–534.
https://doi.org/10.11646/zootaxa.4066.5.1
Taniuchi, T. (1970) Variation in the teeth of the sand shark, Odontaspis taurus (Rafinesque) taken from the East China Sea. Japanese Journal of Ichthyology, 17 (1), 37–44.
Underwood, C., Ward, D. & Guinot, G. (2016) Development of understanding of the Mesozoic and Cenozoic chondrichthyan fossil record. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 430 (1), 155–164.
https://doi.org/10.1144/SP430.4
Voigt, M. & Weber, D. (2011) Field Guide for Sharks of the Genus Carcharhinus. Verlag Dr Friedrich Pfeil, Munich, 151 pp.
Ward, D.J. (1981) A simple machine for bulk processing of clays and silts. Tertiary Research, 3, 121–124.
Weigmann, S. (2016) Annotated checklist of the living sharks, batoids and chimaeras (Chondrichthyes) of the world, with a focus on biogeographical diversity. Journal of Fish Biology, 88 (3), 837–1037.
https://doi.org/10.1111/jfb.12874